Australia tour of India (Feb '17/Mar '17)

The mere suggestion to drop Rahane is lunacy. We are not the India of 20-25 years back, or the Pakistan today where one loss and the whole nation goes bananas. These guys have done well over a period of time and one loss doesn't require any chopping and changing. Even if we lose this series, we have invested a lot in these players and they've done well over a long period of time. We need to give them some rope to redeem slumps in form and confidence. Jayant Yadav himself has done well, but he seems to be someone who can bowl you long spells with some control and contribute well in the lower order. I just feel he's not an out and out match winner with either/or. Kuldeep Yadav is a rare commodity. He is unique and the faster we start grooming him, the quicker he will develop. He, being a left arm wrist spinner also provides a valuable attacking option when playing abroad and keeps our two main spinners honest while adding much needed variety. I've been harping about him for very long and there's clear talent there, likewise with Chahal. The problem is that marquee performances in limited overs label you as some sort of rash-bash specialist.

India in all probability will make one change for Bangalore which will be Nair coming in for J Yadav. No doubt, Nair deserves to be the NO.6 in the pecking order, but our top 5 has to be Vijay, Rahul, Pujara, Kohli and Rahane. For me, those 5 are indispensable and one of the better top 5's going around in Test Match cricket. No need for us to panic about their quality. One thing I will ensure is that Vijay is nowhere catching around the bat or in the slips. He's a world class opener but an absolute calamity waiting to collapse while catching. Also, I'd like him to be a bit more positive with his footwork and batting. A free flowing Vijay is as dangerous as an on song Kohli. He just needs to turn the volume up and get his body language sorted.
 
Any talk in Indian media about what the pitch will be like?
 
I know it wouldn't be possible but I want Abhinav Mukund to play
 
The mere suggestion to drop Rahane is lunacy. We are not the India of 20-25 years back, or the Pakistan today where one loss and the whole nation goes bananas.

I can agree that Indian team has performed well consistently and they should be given time rather than writing off after one big loss, but I can't see change in nation's behavior, We all have seen the swift mood swings of majority of Indian fans here during this first test. Nations behavior tested with consistent losses not with one match and It'd be interesting to see how the behavior goes in the upcoming matches against Australia.
 
I can agree that Indian team has performed well consistently and they should be given time rather than writing off after one big loss, but I can't see change in nation's behavior, We all have seen the swift mood swings of majority of Indian fans here during this first test. Nations behavior tested with consistent losses not with one match and It'd be interesting to see how the behavior goes in the upcoming matches against Australia.

You've not followed Indian cricket in the past two decades then. India were mauled, to be kind, in England & Australia, yet the core composition remained. MS Dhoni continued as captain so be rest assured this top 5 won't be touched. Posts are often made in the heat of the moment. Once calm, like now, we all become clear headed and more reasonable.
 
You've not followed Indian cricket in the past two decades then. India were mauled, to be kind, in England & Australia, yet the core composition remained. MS Dhoni continued as captain so be rest assured this top 5 won't be touched. Posts are often made in the heat of the moment. Once calm, like now, we all become clear headed and more reasonable.

The winning combination did the trick for them and I can agree that Indian board handled the composition way better but winning also played a key role in the consistency. Somewhat PCB did with Misbah, He was captain for 5 to 6 years with loads of match wins behind him but once you start loose consistently with foolish changes in your squad and tactics then every nation goes mad to have drastic meaningful changes.

PS: I believe that Kholi has a long way to go as Captain and as a batsman. Its the early stages but i guess expectations are humongous
 
Dropping Rahane would be a terrible decision. Rahane has been India's star batsman in tests for a long time now. If India treated its stars like this during our heydays, we would not have gotten to see the famed quartret of Sachin, Rahul, Saurav, Laxman. People like Rahane are invaluable to this side and need to be treated properly. Nair will get his chance.

Also I dont understand the sudden overwhelming criticism of Jayant. He did really well in that England series. Yes he was ineffective in Pune, but lets cut him some slack. Yes he needs to be replaced but he did not suddenly become bad overnight.
 
Waiting for ICC's verdict on this pitch , which IMO would be senseless
Because batsmen were getting out mostly on straight balls
What icc verdict? it was the home side who lost not the visting team , no one will complain about this pitch.It would have been a different story if Australia would have lost this people here would then be talking dustbowls stuff and all.The fact of the matter is Australia is leading the series 1 - 0 and the dreams of 4 -0 and chasing 450 is gone.

Pune pitch that would've been on Day 5 of the test match

It looks dangerous
C5pA4joUsAAyFop.jpg
 
The poor rating is completely deserved
 
That is a pathetic pitch. No matter where anyone plays whether home or away, no team deserves that pitch. I remember Delhi's Feroz Shah Kotla was banned after that Sri Lanka game that was called off, same should happen to Pune. Even if an opposition is coming to India to play and if India wants to have some advantage by having spin friendly pitch this is not what is needed. Poor management and BCCI must be fined heavily by ICC and in return Pune should be banned from hosting test matches for atleast after the next home season.
 
You've not followed Indian cricket in the past two decades then. India were mauled, to be kind, in England & Australia, yet the core composition remained. MS Dhoni continued as captain so be rest assured this top 5 won't be touched. Posts are often made in the heat of the moment. Once calm, like now, we all become clear headed and more reasonable.

Thats because this team is very young
 
That is a pathetic pitch. No matter where anyone plays whether home or away, no team deserves that pitch. I remember Delhi's Feroz Shah Kotla was banned after that Sri Lanka game that was called off, same should happen to Pune. Even if an opposition is coming to India to play and if India wants to have some advantage by having spin friendly pitch this is not what is needed. Poor management and BCCI must be fined heavily by ICC and in return Pune should be banned from hosting test matches for atleast after the next home season.
Way better than making roads of yesteryear![DOUBLEPOST=1488324966][/DOUBLEPOST]Rahane is such a mess, sub standard player, please drop him into oblivion!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top