Mafia01 - Classic Mafia - End Game - Mafia (Zhuorb and Swirler) win

[barmyarmy]

Just doing what I have to to stay alive

 

[puddleduck]

Just doing what I have to to stay alive

The fact you feed on the blood of orphans to stay young isn't relevant in this thread

I don't like this game anymore. It's too confusing haha Also get the feeling I might turn up dead tomorrow.

 

[puddleduck]

Awesome Swirler is about, so hopefully he's got something to contribute and that just leaves MaD I think?

 

[CremerCurrans]

Feel very sorry for Sedition as he was playing his first game. I'd like to put on record that I am definitely not mean enough to kill someone playing their first game before they even got a chance to post.

@User - it's a classic 7 player setup so there are two mafia.

Just doing what I have to to stay alive

barmyarmy seems to be protesting way to much, surely you have better things to say, then telling everyone your not mafia every five seconds.

Indeed. No lynch is a legitimate tactic in a longer game but not a shorter one. You only go there as a last resort not a first choice.

@puddleduck - obviously there's nothing I can say to that except that if you're town you need me to help you win

Here he just repeated what User2010 said, then again tells us he's town. quit going on about not being mafia.


It's a shame Sedition got killed off, being a docter and in his first game.

We've heard from everyone now except MaD.

----------

We No Lynch today, no reason to lynch. The only PR left in here is the doctor, he is supposed to out next day IIRC. It's MYLO, we have a better chance of lynching tomorrow. Also, we gotta get this game going on, rather than ranting over the cop death. We need a few more posts to start judging people over their talk.

What does MYLO stand for?

Surprised to see a No Lynch so early, we need as much discussion as possible.

----------

That's it from me for the moment, heading out for the day.

FOS: barmyarmy & Zhuorb

I'd like to hear more from both.

----------

Edit: FOS: barmyarmy & Zhuorb

 

[puddleduck]

Sedition was the cop...

So I'm ruling Swirler out from being the Doc, which isn't surprising, since I've hinted I might be and as such could be a target tonight (save me real doc).

Well, at least this should be confusing the mafia haha.

Swirler, I think you've been very quick to just do exactly what you've accused Barmy of doing...

You're heading out, which is convenient, and you've commented once nearly everyone has. Barmy hasn't really said he's Town, he's just confirmed (as an experienced player I assume) what User said about small games not needing a No Lynch first night (I could be getting led along here though).

I'm all for leaving Barmy tonight, because I think he's dug himself a hole that will either see him targetted or he's potential mafia.

----------

Another thought... my head will start hurting soon heh...

This game took a while to kick off properly with the Mafia having a while to think. As a result they would have known first that the game was going to start soon, because they would have gotten their roles in... As such, I'm thinking MaD might well be civilian as he wouldn't know it's started yet.

I also think whoever got involved first is potentially dodgy.

Keep FOS: Zhuorb

----------

Worst possible start, cop is such an important role in such a small game.
This can mean there are two mafias? Surely, more than 2 can't be there. I think there's a GF and a goon. We have a cop, a doc, and 3 more townies (plain?)

Little bit confused by this actually. I've never played this before, but I was more than capable of reading the posts saying how many of what was in the game.

As someone who has successfully manipulated the GF role before, why were you so clueless at this point?

 

[puddleduck]

Ok, one final piece of paranoia (I think I'll have successfully pointed the finger at everyone now haha).

MaD was last online at 12... Hedger suggested at 10 he was waiting for the last Mafia role.. He dissapeared shortly after the first proper post...

So MaD, you just gonna admit you're mafia then?

 

[barmyarmy]

barmyarmy seems to be protesting way to much, surely you have better things to say, then telling everyone your not mafia every five seconds.

Like Puddleduck said I haven't said that and you're seeing things. Nice try...

Here he just repeated what User2010 said, then again tells us he's town. quit going on about not being mafia.

Actually I said it first so he repeated what I said and I then elaborated on it.

You've made a pretty aggressive opening post which is intriguing. Usually aggressive posts like that are designed to deflect attention and seeing as Zhuorb was the only one who had been FOSed...

That said I'm going to add an FOS onto MaD as he tends to start mafia games really slowly and might need some persuasion

Nothing has really stood out for me so far apart from Zhuorb. User2010 always plays a very close game which is hard to read and Puddleduck hasn't played before so can't get a great read there.

 

[puddleduck]

Puddleduck hasn't played before so can't get a great read there.

If it helps, this is the graphical representation of my brain processes over this thread so far -

 

[puddleduck]

Quick question?

How long do we get until Hedger calls it night time? Does everyone basically have to place either a lynch or no lynch call before that happens? Wouldn't like to think it could just suddenly be night and we haven't really had any input from MaD?

 

[barmyarmy]

He'll give about 24 hours warning normally. Remember not to edit your posts during mafia games.

 

[puddleduck]

Yeah I wouldn't normally, but the picture dissapeared so I re-uploaded it to PC

----------

... and thanks

 

[MaD]

Can't post if I'm sleeping...

Zhuorb trying to kick it off with a no lynch does seem rather dodgy, need more posts from him though.
Barmy seems paranoid though
Also, hedger never said he was waiting for the final role, he just said he was giving them time to discuss some more.
pd's giving me town vibes, not sure about swirler so for now,

Lynch: barmyarmy

I'd like a claim from him...

 

[puddleduck]

There's absolutely no reason to lynch Barmy based on what he's posted so far.

Not even an FOS? A straight up lynch? I had my doubts about MaD based on nothing more than everyone else's posts, and this actually adds to them. For example, you're the only person who spotted my deliberate mistake about what Hedger said. I know it's aimed at you, but a mafia would definitely know that Hedger had just given them more time.

Also, you seem to have been the only person who has not been too keen on getting an early lynch on Zhuorb... Your buddy perhaps? I for some reason had a feeling the first to try and push, and the last to get involved could be working together...

I'm more confused than a 20 year old George Michael

FOS: MaD and Zhuorb

----------

Furthermore, why so keen to get Barmy to role claim if it isn't to try and decide whether me or him are the doc

 

[MaD]

What's the point in FOS ing, all it says is that that person seems scummy.
I don't expect anyone to follow my lynch since it was just a pressure lynch.

Come to think of it, you're right, we wouldn't want the doc to claim so no I don't want barmy to claim.

Zhuorb's made one post, so I can't really judge him that much, but it was scummy. I have no problem with lynching Zhuorb, if his next posts seem scummy too.

It wasn't hard to pick out your mistake, I read that post of Hedger's and knew what it said, I was just pointing out that your logic of me being mafia was incorrect.

 

[puddleduck]

Well I'd like User to answer my question as to why he was so slopppy early on and didn't seem to have read the outline of the game? Specifically trying to seem like he doesn't know as much as he actually does know as someone in the Mafia?

I'd also like to hear from Zhuorb again. Plays a big role in confirming or denying some of my other suspicions depending on what he says

I don't trust Swirler either.