Medical Mafia 02 - Endgame (mafia wins)

[Sulaiman7]

@IceAgeComing officially replaces Khaleel.

 

[IceAgeComing]

Yo, I'm replacing in. Let me have some time to read through the thread and do a little work: should be able to dhare my thoughts at some point this evening!

 

[thedon5]

Yo, I'm replacing in. Let me have some time to read through the thread and do a little work: should be able to dhare my thoughts at some point this evening!

Uh oh, not this again.

There is no need to read through the thread at this point in the game.

 

[khaleel]

Sorry guys, I'm a bit busy at the moment. Nice to see IceAgeComing replace me, hopefully he can contribute more than me. All the best everyone.

 

[WORLD CHAMPIONS]

Looks like i am late

 

[ved_]

Look who's back.

----------

Here's what we could do.

1- Simon
2- thedon5
3- yashdude101
4- hedger_14
5- Umair2000
6- Iceagecoming
7- Surendar
8- Dipak
9- Zhuorb

Use your night role on the person above you in the list. Simon will be on me, don on Simon and so on.

 

[thedon5]

Look who's back.

----------

Here's what we could do.

1- Simon
2- thedon5
3- yashdude101
4- hedger_14
5- Umair2000
6- Iceagecoming
7- Surendar
8- Dipak
9- Zhuorb

Use your night role on the person above you in the list. Simon will be on me, don on Simon and so on.

Well that would just be stupid... People should use their judgement.

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[hedger_14]

Well that would just be stupid... People should use their judgement.

That's a horrible strategy. Mafia can work out most of the roles based on what happens during the night. Mafia can kill the person above them on the list knowing they won't be saved and claim that they must be the quack or that person was the weak doctor. And unless the jailkeeper is below the quack, the quack will kill someone, so you're pretty much playing even more roulette with the hope that the quack sits below a mafia member. Mafia will also know who is/who isn't the weak doctor based on whether the players below them die.

This isn't exact but the only thing to gain from doing that is more info for the mafia. Thus, pick a random person to target and don't out it until tomorrow at least.

Anyway, I'm placing a No Lynch because I am good at forgetting to log into PC. Don't follow me though if you want to discuss more.

 

[ved_]

Doesn't this just have a bunch of doctors and we have to find the mafia?

----------

Oh crap. I confused this with a setup on EM

----------

Nvm screw that strat.

 

[thedon5]

Doesn't this just have a bunch of doctors and we have to find the mafia?

----------

Oh crap. I confused this with a setup on EM

----------

Nvm screw that strat.

That seems to always be your excuse... And yes, it is just a bunch of doctors (and a nurse) and we have to find the Mafia.

It was a terrible idea for sure.

I'm not desperate for any more discussion, we have gotten into the game and should have a good grip now. All we need now is a replacement for Dipak.

No Lynch

 

[Villain]

Looks like i am late

You can still replace Dipak, who seems inactive and is yet to even confirm his role. I don't know why the replacement still haven't been taken into account.
@Sulaiman7 Can we?

----------

Look who's back.

----------

Here's what we could do.

1- Simon
2- thedon5
3- yashdude101
4- hedger_14
5- Umair2000
6- Iceagecoming
7- Surendar
8- Dipak
9- Zhuorb

Use your night role on the person above you in the list. Simon will be on me, don on Simon and so on.

Seriously?
Well, that just won't work.

 

[thedon5]

you can still replace dipak, who seems inactive and is yet to even confirm his role. I don't know why the replacement still haven't been taken into account.
@sulaiman7 can we?

noooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Villain]

why? cause we could random lynch the mafia in you? Lynching today means regardless of night actions, the game won't be over tomorrow, therefore random lynching is not the worst thing to do, just in this case probably not optimal.

Agree there, might not be the worst but not optimal at the moment. I just can't buy it right now, maybe later..

----------

noooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!

Why? Is he that good?

 

[thedon5]

Why? Is he that good?

Not quite...

This should explain it very well...

http://www.planetcricket.org/forums/mafia-games-forum/ashes-ashes-mafia-endgame-sk-win-84986.html