End Game Prison Break Mafia! - Town Wins! The inmates (RUDI, SamSax., FP, CK, PS) escape!

[Gaurav_7]

As much as we are all interested, and your right that it could be a giveaway, I think its only fair that we dont talk about substitutions. If we're deducing that Sod was under pressure hence bailed, or that the Mod replaced him quick smart, its not really fair on the incoming player to be able to use that.

I agree the incoming player will be at a disadvantage and hence I asked the reason and Yash needs to clarify this.

 

[Fake Passport]

I agree the incoming player will be at a disadvantage and hence I asked the reason and Yash needs to clarify this.

Any more information puts the incoming player at more of a disadvantage though...

If Sodium won the lottery and went to the Bahamas, then everyone would go 'well, Yash was quick to replace him'.
If Sodium said he wasn't coping with the pressure, everyone would go 'Thats because he was scum'. Any generic answer would tend towards this.
That even assumes that Yash was given a reason in the first place, and that the reason is something that is able to be disclosed publicly.

@Yash. I suggest you just say move on. This brings it inline with standard mafia rules on larger sites eg. MU - Rule9

 

[Gaurav_7]

I agree with that view too. But it is kinda weird to leave midway. Anyways let's move on. @RUDI needs to speak now.

 

[CerealKiller]

People speculating on the substitution are very suspicious. Are they trying to imply that Sodium was scum and couldn't handle the pressure, so he bailed?

 

[El Loco]

Don't really see what Rudi can say, as a totally different player, to clarify anything Sodium did. Could've been one of many reasons as to why he replied the way he did, for all he knows.

 

[Yash.]

Don't think about quitting because not coping up with pressure. Sod was not able to devote much time so asked to be replaced.

 

[Gaurav_7]

People speculating on the substitution are very suspicious. Are they trying to imply that Sodium was scum and couldn't handle the pressure, so he bailed?

I can speak for myself and I just wanted to know why in the mid game Sod left. That is why I mentioned it as weird. I get it can be something personal and can't be made public.

Don't really see what Rudi can say, as a totally different player, to clarify anything Sodium did. Could've been one of many reasons as to why he replied the way he did, for all he knows.

If you are replying to mine post, I meant in general that Rudi has to speak now. He doesn't actually need to clarify anything. Only Yash as a game mod should do it and that too if he feels the need.

 

[RUDI]

Role received @Yash.

If Sodium said he wasn't coping with the pressure, everyone would go 'Thats because he was scum'. Any generic answer would tend towards this.

I highly doubt most mafia players will drop out of a Mafia game if they indeed had a PR like what you are referring to. Hopefully you will not try and build a case around this
'That's because he was scum' ^

Just a quick observation: Rebel & Fake seems to enjoy each others company way more than the rest of the players company.

 

[Fake Passport]

Im ready to FOS Rebel.
Everything screams wanting to frame up Sodium, his post about the vigilante tonally sounds like its written from someone hiding something, and he was quite keen for more info from the game mod to further implicate him.
Yet there hasn't really been a reason, aside from agreeing with Villain about defensiveness, which is fine, but carried on a little far into the day IMO. I wonder if Reb is trying to frame up a seeingly convenient and easy target?

 

[Fake Passport]

Role received @Yash.
I highly doubt most mafia players will drop out of a Mafia game if they indeed had a PR like what you are referring to. Hopefully you will not try and build a case around this
'That's because he was scum' ^

But such is the accusations that will fly no matter what Yash says, thats my point. The reason 'why' there was a substitution should be off-limits for open discussion IMO.
Not what Sodium posts, or indeed if what you and him seemingly conflict, then ill be the first to orchestrate a lynch, its the speculation and attempt to get info from the game mod for something that is substantially external from the game I'm advocating against.

 

[El Loco]

I am surprised that Rebel was expecting an explicit response from the mod as to why Sodium was replaced. This stage of the game of is nowhere near enough time to have a scum read on someone though, whether in the case of Sodium based on what he posted, or Rebel thus far. Quite early to be throwing accusations about IMO.

 

[RUDI]

Wow this setup looks great! I am in whenever the signups open.

Yeah open setup is defo advantage to mafia but Yash is inexperienced as far as forum mafia is concerned so we got to play as it is.

I seriously doubt vig will be able to kill each night? If that is actually the case it will be a killing spree, each night! We do have a RB but still 2 kills each night is going to be deadly. We got to be very careful in our lynches. Atm I would like to hear a bit from Sodium.

@Yash. I hope rebel isn't pushing you around too much via PM because of your "inexperience"?

@Rebel2k17 , just a quick question: Why the excitement and optimism initially when you saw the setup, and after receiving your role you seem to be overcautious and a little less optimistic?

 

[Fake Passport]

^^ Thats a good catch. What I alluded to together with that im happy to make the pressure a little more formal.

Lynch @Rebel2k17

 

[Villain]

FP all a sudden changing stance, from kinda agreeing with Rebel to from nowhere lynching him just after Rudi thought there's some connection is fishy. He sounded like he was shaken up after that post.
FOS: Fake Passport

About Sodium, well whatever reason has been put up of him leaving the game.. I agree with Rebel that he was too defensive and would've been one to keep a watch on later in the game.

 

[RUDI]

Setup

1 SerialKiller.

1 Mafia Godfather.
1 Mafia Goon

@Yash. Please be so kind to give the winning conditions here publically. That would greatly assist us in the game.