The Australian batting line up has a very fragile look to it, even before it showed how brittle it is. We have 2 junior openers, one of whom has zip experience at 1st class level let alone International, the 2 most experienced batsman are 3 and 4 then we are into what appears to be either the tail or a very badly ordered line up. D Hussey seems to find this a step too far, Haddin is batting too high for a guy who is under pressure to prove he can keep, Hopes either should be batting a little further down if he is playing as an all rounder. White appears to be playing as a specialist batsman but comes in at 7. If he isn't going to bowl there are better options, he is mediocre in the field and only occasionally comes of as a batsman.
The selectors appear to be picking names out of their ..... without any planning. Certainly Waner may have the goods, but one swallow doesn't a summer make, and he needs experience and balance to help him. Perhaps the side would look a bit better with someone like Kattich opening with him, an older head to keep him on even keel, this would allow Marsh to move to 4 and Hussey can come in a 5 or 6. he earned a reputation as one of the great finishers but we have him up the order. I'd like to see a better spin option then either Hauritz or White who are both straight turners. Haddin, if he is to be retained and Hopes can come in next. The spin option bats either at 5 or 8. WHo plays as the spinner is a little problematical.