End Game Star Wars Mafia - End Mafia(Surendar) & Third Party (Fake Passport) Won

[CremerCurrans]

Well played scum, two of our power roles, are gone..

Surendar was vanilla townie, so only one town power role is gone.

Town - Fake, Rudolph, El Loco (?)

Do you honestly think Fake Passport is town aligned? I have been one of his biggest supporters, however my beleif is that he is third party. I support him because we need his vote to lynch the mafia.

 

[Fake Passport]

^ LOL - You were on my list of people to maybe vote for. I was going to ISO you and potentially advocate for your lynch, if I do that now it just looks OMGUS, esp with Villain yesterday.

I was an early advocate (if not first) of offing Villain. I'm hoping that buys me some town cred...

 

[CremerCurrans]

if I do that now it just looks OMGUS, esp with Villain yesterday.

What does this mean?

I was an early advocate (if not first) of offing Villain. I'm hoping that buys me some town cred...

This post bothers me. Of course you would advocate for someone to be lynched when they are misunderstanding what you are posting, and also wanting to lynch you off. How could you possibly know for sure that Villain was mafia? Does Rudolph deserve equal credit for his lynch on Villain? There was much more evidence proving that he was anti-town when the later people lynched him. The credit you should receive is for putting early pressure on Villain, which resulted in him posting a scummy role claim.

 

[Fake Passport]

OMGUS is parlance for 'Oh my god you suck' which is basically voting for someone when they vote for you. It kinda implies and emotional vote over a logical/rational one.

when they are misunderstanding what you are posting, and also wanting to lynch you off.

FtR, I think villain knew exactly what he was doing. I don't think there was any misunderstanding.

And on your second point, you don't have to vote for someone becuase they are voting for you, infact that is a really weak reason on the whole, which was the point of my above post and I find it odd you would say that tbh.

I dont really care how much cred I get for Villain, I know a few people had scum suspicions on me and just wanting to illustrate I picked Villain and was all for getting rid of him right through, just a fact I want people to remember

 

[CremerCurrans]

OMGUS is parlance for 'Oh my god you suck' which is basically voting for someone when they vote for you. It kinda implies and emotional vote over a logical/rational one.

Thanks.

FtR, I think villain knew exactly what he was doing. I don't think there was any misunderstanding.

Of course, with hindsight on our side, it appears that Villain thought you would be an easy target.

And on your second point, you don't have to vote for someone becuase they are voting for you, infact that is a really weak reason on the whole, which was the point of my above post and I find it odd you would say that tbh.

It makes sense that your lynch would be based on more than just that. I keep looking at your post above, and what you typed appears defensive to me.

I dont really care how much cred I get for Villain, I know a few people had scum suspicions on me and just wanting to illustrate I picked Villain and was all for getting rid of him right through, just a fact I want people to remember

I'm happy to give you credit for causing the scummy claim from Villain, however that won't stop me questioning your role. It would be silly for me to consider you fully town considering what has happened in the game.

 

[Till Valhalla]

24 hours for deadline.

 

[RUDI]

Lynch : swacker
@Jack Ryder
More of a pressure lynch than anything else. Several of us have FOS'ed him as scum and he hasn't responded to it.

 

[Fake Passport]

I suspect the surendar kill was to try to get us to lynch Loco as much as anything. To me Loco is lock town so I'm not entertaining it.

I'm not quite where Rudi is with lynching swacker, mainly because he could be a town PR. But I would like to see some pressure on him (along with Simon and CC) but for now...

There's really nothing to go off of right now, so I guess we just wait for others to post.

Aight, I am away for a while if you could believe. Having exams atm, but I am watching the thread be up to date. Haven't posted much, but it doesn't mean you @Varun can just have a lynch on the basis of not taking any risk.

I don't want to be the person that ends up dying extremely early in the game for my theories that may not even be correct later in the game, reason for me not posting much.

If we get to a later day with few people left, I'll come back and kick some mafia ass. Or if questions come by.

Emphasis added by me. Which one is it primarily? Either you were absent because you had exams or because its deliberate. Given your post early about waiting for others I think its deliberate on your part. I guess it could be deliberate because you have exams, but why change stories? It seemed to me that the exams (which I have no reason to doubt) came up once you got a bit of pressure.

Haven't read much of posts, will add my thoughts soon. (I am away atm)

You haven't as yet - please do.

 

[Fake Passport]

24 hours for deadline.

Youve been awesome with this, but if activity allows it could you extend by 12ish hours? Gives me some kid free time to have a proper read...

 

[Till Valhalla]

activity allows it could you extend by 12ish hours?

Definitely if needed.

 

[swacker]

Emphasis added by me. Which one is it primarily? Either you were absent because you had exams or because its deliberate. Given your post early about waiting for others I think its deliberate on your part. I guess it could be deliberate because you have exams, but why change stories?

I don't know what idea you have, but I haven't been active about a week, though I am observing the thread as much as I could.

Not only I had exams, I wanted to change my gameplay.

 

[swacker]

And before people jump in 'not contributing', I haven't found a clue on who seems scum. Initially thought asprin was one, but it wasn't so I wanted to wait for something to happen before getting into conclusion.

Mafia are playing pretty well atm, haven't got my eyes on anyone yet. Varun backing CC was kinda weird at the start, then again El Loco is pretty much under the hood for a while.

 

[SiriusBlack]

I was an early advocate (if not first) of offing Villain. I'm hoping that buys me some town cred...

I thought we agreed that people to lynch Villain weren't necessarily clean?
I mean, sure, you were an early supporter which is more credible, but I find it interesting that you choose to "buy some town cred" so directly.[DOUBLEPOST=1501007163][/DOUBLEPOST]I can't really see a third party in this setup tbh. Forgive me if I'm wrong bc I'm not that big on Star Wars (only watched The Force Awakens) but the Star Wars theme doesn't really have a third party involved does it? It's just two sides fighting each other? In a mafia context with a game this large, I could def see a third party but I'm not sure that it falls within the theme.

 

[Till Valhalla]

Lynch Count
Swacker - Rudolph

Thank you everyone, Everybody(Myself Included) had a bit of doubt that 12 members might be too much and the game will fail but everyone has did a great job keeping the game active. We are at the 14 position in the most replies in Mafia Section (A little brag wouldn't hurt anybody).

 

[El Loco]

surendar was killed because he was the only player cleared of nearly all suspicion so far.

We don't have a roleblocker as I said it the post above because no one counterclaimed against Villain. The doctor protected the town on Night 1 it seems.

Seems reasonable to assume. That leaves the Doc role then, not keen for them to out, but hopefully they'll have accurate town reads to know who to protect.

Interestingly Villain used the same phrasing as Fake Passport while claiming his role but I think that should actually clear Fake because he was probably trying to just copy him to make us suspicious of Fake just in case Villain would get lynched, which he did.

I do like the logic used here, but it doesn't clear him of being third party. Yash would have just known that he wasn't Mafia. That is, if Fake Passport isn't Mafia himself.

Was reading through for people mentioning Villain, and just dug these posts out from Varun. Seems like an attempt to clear him from a lynch before he went in himself. I feel like that's more of an attempt to clear himself out of suspicion in the following day. And again, he was the one to clear surendar out and encouraged people not to lynch him, and then

From my observation it was only Varun who cleared surendar for the most part. Loco and myself both had reads on him, and I don't remember anyone else clearing surendar completely. Surendar also had leads on CC and Varun that he was trying to bring into the limelight but couldn't, and that was overshadowed yesterday with everyone jumping onto Villain.

This post didn't directly trigger it, but I have had the thought that Varun could have pretended to be nit picky in order to suddenly find something to clear Surendar, but in actual fact he could just be Mafia who knew Surendar was town all along (since he did claim VT) and just bought himself some brownie points to back him as town, knowing that he was going to target him soon anyway. Knowing as little as I do in this game, this is not that far-fetched of a theory I don't think. Not sticking anything on Varun, but I don't think anyone deserves a free pass as of yet.

^ LOL - You were on my list of people to maybe vote for. I was going to ISO you and potentially advocate for your lynch, if I do that now it just looks OMGUS, esp with Villain yesterday.

I was an early advocate (if not first) of offing Villain. I'm hoping that buys me some town cred...

Despite the fact that you were the second person to lynch him, your reason for doing so didn't seem right to me, especially the manner in which you did it, as I didn't know Villain was Mafia at the time.