MUFC1987 said:
Credit to Saj, even though he was out really. I told you all it was a 300 pitch. We just need to get rid of Yardy and Read and we'd have a decent side. Although Blackwell should be in ahead of Dalrymple with a decent keeper/batsman.
Blackwell did alright but his batting has not been at JDs standard, not to mention Blackies fielding :help
MUFC - On Yardy, I agree he's been poor, but who was at the end with Saj when we beat Pakistan when we were collapsing?
Yardys been out of form, he had a bad day today, but he's by no far the worst England player in an ODI shirt. Clarke, McGrath, etc. He's a good player, he's not been bowling 'spin' for long, he is out of form though. I know he's better he's a late improver though, only really coming into the game (ie starting regularly for Sussex at the age of 23).
Read though, I can't defend he's doing nowt, although Bravos slower ball is very good he's not done much since his comeback test. But they'd only bring back Geraint "Let's sweep the spinners" Jones. Could we go with Davies early? I'd say keep Read for a little longer (Jones played out of form for over a year, so why not?).
As for todays performance, well done England, although I find it ironic that we won but didn't really play all that well as a team, a couple of partnerships when batting but nothing huge although a good start. Lewis and JD bowled well, others average with Jimmy being poor, Saj couple of wickets good ball to dismiss Lara but a little expensive. Lewis impressed me though, people said he couldn't do it outside of England (albeit we can hardly judge him on one game) but he did really well today, nothing beats accuracy.
All I'll say is keep faith in Yardy especially in One Day Cricket because he is so important to our success and invariably contributes when Sussex win.
angryangy said:
In this lineup, Jones would comfortably come in no later than six. Why have they picked such a team? We all know there are still batsmen of skill lurking about England. Are all rounders worth having almost no middle order?
Remember though Freddie has been a batsman for most of the tournament. I'd expect Tres to come in for Yardy in our next ODI (VB series?).
As for the keeper, I'd go for Prior, but it'll be Jones, don't know why he clearly can't do it at international level, like Read.