Classic Mafia 02 - The End

[Villain]

My conclusion is that I want to lynch either Sulaiman or Simon.

A role claim from Simon then? He's online right now.

 

[Abhas]

No, role claims aren't going to help. They would complicate matters further, unless we get the claims from everyone, which would be a stupid thing to do.

 

[Villain]

What more can we do then for now? None of us know when would Sulaiman get over here and defend himself.

 

[thedon5]

I'll do a little ranking like surendar did for my current thoughts.

Abhas
surendar
hedger
Sulaiman7
Simon

No offence to pallu, but to me he is a bit clueless. That doesn't make him Mafia. Simon knows what he's doing a bit more I think, and even though he usually plays like this, it still isn't an ideal way to play. Fact is all of us have very little to work off, we still post something to try and scum hunt. He is posting very little, just giving his views without a real desire to go after anyone, until the notion that one of him or Sulaiman had to be lynched off, at which point he proceeded to try and save himself.

Sulaiman has also just been inactive overall in the whole of PC, which is a different kettle of fish. to being inactive in just the thread, though I am not trying to let him off for this.

Surendar for me has played well since joining and has defused suspicions I had of User, for now at least.

I am convinced for now I think that we aren't going to get anything else from the day. So I am ready to make my decision.

Lynch: Simon

 

[Villain]

Lynch: Simon
I seriously want a role claim from him.

 

[thedon5]

A role claim is useless as anyone with a brain will claim one thing and one thing only now that a cop counter-claim isn't really wise any more.

 

[Villain]

A role claim is useless as anyone with a brain will claim one thing and one thing only now that a cop counter-claim isn't really wise any more.

It'd still have been something we can talk about. Anyway, lets see what others have to say. I'll stick with my lynch.
I guess it takes four to lynch?

 

[Abhas]

Unless he claims Doc, and he is counter claimed by the other doc, we cannot ascertain his alignment on the basis of his claim, and that would mean, sacrificing the doc. We would have to look at the general gameplay, and hints that could lead us somewhere.

 

[Villain]

Unless he claims Doc, and he is counter claimed by the other doc, we cannot ascertain his alignment on the basis of his claim, and that would mean, sacrificing the doc. We would have to look at the general gameplay, and hints that could lead us somewhere.

That makes sense but what keeps you from not lynching him off?

 

[AbhishekS]

Okay, so I have lost track of who has casted a lynch vote and on whom! :P

Will be nice if everyone posts their lynch status.

Current lynches (of which I'm aware of)
thedon5 - Simon (1)
Simon - Sulaiman7 (1)
yashdude101 - Simon (2)
hedger_14 - null
Abhas - null
Surendar - null
Sulaiman7 - null

Are these correct? The figures in bracket indicate vote counts. Person to get 4 votes will be lynched when we have all 'non-null' votes.

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[AbhishekS]

BTW how's the idea of searching a replacement for Sulaiman? Maybe @Varun would be interested.

 

[Abhas]

Ideally, the doc should now have the best idea about the game. He protected a townie, knows the cop, and his pro-town result, which makes 4 people (if of-course there wasn't an overlap).
He can easily figure out, out of the remaining 3 people, which is town, and which is mafia. If only he can analyse his result, and the game, we might have broken through.

----------

As for wanting to let this day pass, well it was only because we weren't really going anywhere. Say the night did come, the doc would know who to protect - the cop I.e. Thedon. The mafia would think that's pretty obvious and would go after someone else with a 1/4 chance of getting the doc. Even if they did get someone it would basically go back to being a lethal Night 0, only with cop getting another shot at finding out the mafia, this time with a better chance of getting the mafia.

How can you be certain that you would still be alive start of day 2?
And, no, the mafia would easily figure out who the doc is by tomorrow. It doesn't take rocket science, just a simple case of permutations, so this wouldn't mean it's back to a lethal night 0. Mafia know the cop, they know the confirmed townie, and possibly might have figured out the doc too.

 

[Villain]

BTW how's the idea of searching a replacement for Sulaiman? Maybe @Varun would be interested.

Good idea, it'd build up the interest and keep it going.
And the lynch count is spot on.

 

[Abhas]

That makes sense but what keeps you from not lynching him off?

A defence is what I'm waiting for.